MANSFIELD, MA— First it was a piece of a toast, now it's a metal pizza tray.

Josh Mather sees the image of Jesus on a burnt metal pizza tray. Mather said he sees Jesus on the left and Mary on the right. The tray was part of an old brick pizza oven in the restaurant he owned with his brother. The restaurant is currently closed, and the tray was stashed in Mather's garage for months.

Tuesday, Mather noticed the tray. And the next day, coincidentally Ash Wednesday, Mather went to church for the first time in 20 years.